MedicalVirtual vs Smith.ai
MedicalVirtual (dedicated, $8–$12/hour) against Smith.ai (shared, $300/mo (30 calls) to $2,100/mo (300 calls)).
On this page
Verdict
MedicalVirtual for any medical desk: HIPAA training and BAA stated, scheduling included, one named person. Smith.ai's per-call pricing is tidy for very low volumes, but scheduling is an add-on and the pricing page is silent on HIPAA.
Side by side
| MedicalVirtual | Smith.ai | |
|---|---|---|
| Frontdesk score | 4.5/5 | 2.6/5 |
| Type | Dedicated | Shared |
| Published price | $8–$12/hour | $300/mo (30 calls) to $2,100/mo (300 calls) |
| Low volume (50 calls / 15 hrs) | $520–$779/month estimated (hourly only; no published monthly price) | $810 + $75 scheduling (90 calls) |
| Medium (150 calls / 25 hrs) | $866–$1,299/month estimated (hourly only; no published monthly price) | $2,100 + $225 scheduling (300 calls) |
| High (400 calls / 40 hrs) | $1,386–$2,078/month estimated (hourly only; no published monthly price) | $2,100+ (exceeds largest plan) |
| Coverage | Business hours — Full | 24/7 — 24/7 |
| HIPAA | HIPAA training and BAA stated | No HIPAA or BAA statement on pricing page |
| Scheduling | Included | Included |
| Works inside your EHR | Yes | Via calendar/scheduling tools |
| Same person every call | Yes | No — shared team |
| Team location | Latin America | North America-based agents |
| Best for | Practices that want a named, part-time assistant on an hourly rate | Practices with low call volume that want per-call rather than per-minute billing |
| Wrong choice if | You need someone physically in the office, pooled 24/7 overflow answering from a single part-time seat, or a US-citizen assistant for policy reasons. | Any practice that needs HIPAA stated or scheduling included |
Prices from provider pages, 8 November 2026. Shared estimates assume 4 minutes per call and the smallest covering plan; dedicated estimates are rate × hours × 4.33.
Scorecards
4.5/5Frontdesk score
- Hours & coverage
- 8
- Works in your systems
- 9
- HIPAA posture
- 9
- Price clarity & value
- 9
- Continuity (same person)
- 10
2.6/5Frontdesk score
- Hours & coverage
- 10
- Works in your systems
- 6
- HIPAA posture
- 3
- Price clarity & value
- 5
- Continuity (same person)
- 2
Published 8 November 2026 · Last reviewed 8 November 2026 · Report an error
